Another view

Posted on by

Photo by MZ

Isn’t this a pretty picture?

I took it last week at Cranbrook, a little slice of heaven tucked away in a suburb of Detroit. You know Detroit, subject of network TV documentaries about things like industrial wastelands and economic war zones and cities of heartbreak and hope? The Cranbrook campus, which features a prestigious private school, science and art museums, and 40 acres of woods, fields and garden paths along a small lake and several streams, isn’t part of Detroit city proper. But Detroit is more than what is contained within its city limits. It is a sprawling region made up of a decaying center city as well as its myriad suburbs spread out along the Detroit River, adjacent Lake St. Clair ,and stretching north and west toward countless inland lakes, rivers and streams.

There are trees and parks and boulevards and other interesting things within Detroit city limits. But you won’t see them on a network TV show. What you get is what’s now being billed as “ruin porn.” You get images of despair and decay because that’s what people in California and New York and Florida and Texas think is Detroit. Why clear anything up for anyone outside of the “flyover zone?”

Photo by MZ

Look at this picture.

This is how Dateline NBC depicted Detroit in its Sunday feature. It’s not as warm and fuzzy as the first. The bare branches suggest death, decay and abandonment. I took this picture minutes before the image of the flowering tree at  Cranbrook gardens. This gnarled old-timer crouches over a lake within 1,000 feet of the happy pink lady.  Same place. Two different views.

See how easy it is in any given situation to play up the good or focus entirely on the bad? What’s apparently too difficult to do is to craft a report that shows the many layers of a complicated situation. It’s easier to show the same tired images of our abandoned train station, the bums in the gutter, the wayward youth, the noble poor woman feeding, clothing and housing  three babies on $200 a week, and, of course,  the crazy guy shooting and barbecuing raccoons in his yard.

I was disappointed that Dateline didn’t showcase a wider view of our region and include some images of Detroit’s many preserved neighborhoods and cultural treasures, of the many movers and shakers who work tirelessly to establish smart and innovative programs to reinvent this “city of heartbreak and hope.”

I’m not going to sugar coat things here. The reports themselves are not wrong. We have crime. We have corruption. We have massive urban decay. We have poverty and illiteracy and many other woes. We are the epicenter of the economic collapse. But, the Detroit area is so much more than the gnarled, half-dead tree and the crazy coon man.  There are still a few pink ladies twirling out in the open yet they remain invisible to the national media.

Here are a few responses to that show if you’d like to hear the rest of the story:

The mayor of Detroit responds.

Reaction by a former journalist who was interviewed for the story.

A Web site with some beautiful images of Detroit that you’ll never see on a network show about Detroit.

Reblog this post [with Zemanta]

11 thoughts on “Another view”

  1. So, so true. People hear my parents have a house in Detroit and they automatically assume it’s a horrible place. Not true. Nice neighborhood, actually. I liked living there.

    Nothing fair and balanced about those documentaries, really. But then, isn’t that the way it works these days?
    .-= TeacherMommy´s last blog ..To Tell the Tooth =-.

    Reply ↓

  4. I’m pretty sure all the news shows have a weekly meeting and pick a city to trash and then find the worst of it. I saw a show where Detroit was mentioned, and it did talk about the bad parts, but it also went to great lengths to say that it is a really great place to live, the city is poised for an upswing, and there are lovely places all around. I wish I could remember where I saw it. I want to say Stossel but I can’t be sure. As far as I am concerned Detroit is part of the Midwest so it is a much better place to live than some of the other cities on either coast. Your pictures are beautiful.
    .-= Jen´s last blog ..Tribal Blogs is Too Much Fun! =-.

    Reply ↓

  5. TeacherMommy: True. The house and neighborhood your parents live in has a feel to it that cannot be duplicated in the newer suburbs.
    Libby: You are right about Utah. I guess we have sensitivities to our own turf.
    Jen: Thanks for the tip; I’ll look that one up.

    Reply ↓

  6. Its beautiful.. I loved this post bc no matter how much blight there is (Oakland, Detroit, Pittsburg, etc.) there are always amazing pockets of beauty, accomplishment and wonder. Thanks for sharing some of Detroits.

    Reply ↓

  9. Ruin and decay makes a much more interesting news story. I am pleased to hear that there are other parts of Detroit. I can’t stand hearing about any total ruination of a city. Whether Detroit or anywhere else.

    Reply ↓

  11. I love the first photo. I actually like the second one too for different reasons, but you’re right, it’s not as warm and fuzzy as the first. I missed the Dateline episode. Will have to check out clips. Did I tell you I will be there in June for my niece’s graduation? Maybe we can meet IRL? I will send info via email. xo

    Reply ↓

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge