I'm not buying this story

I’m steering through the heavy rain in the predawn, listening to radio news, when an item nearly takes me off the road: Woman didn’t know she was pregnant until she gave birth. 

Check it out for yourself: 

They even included sound bites from the 911 call in which the dispatcher and the mother discuss cleaning up the infant to clear airways and tie off the umbilical cord. The dad swears it was a huge surprise to everyone. (Side note: They already have three other children.)

I’m sorry, but I’m not buying it. 


I realize some women may not know they are pregnant during the first trimester. I questioned this at one time, but I’ve talked to a few women personally about this who explained to me how this might happen. Some women have medical issues or physical situations that might obscure pregnancy symptoms. 

But not for nine months. Not three trimesters. This is hard to digest. Impossible to swallow. Even though the medical community says it can happen.

I’ve been pregnant. I’m one of those hyper-sensitive types who knew I was pregnant in the first month. I just knew. Something was different. Physically and mentally, I felt a huge shift. I knew before I knew.

By the time my pregnancy was apparent, there was no denying it to anyone, certainly not myself. You might be able to attribute extra pounds to a bad diet. Blame those first butterfly flutters in your abdomen on gas. But by the eighth month, when the fetus is kicking and nearly threatening to tear apart your internal organs, not all the beans in Whole Foods could produce that kind of gas.

Unless a woman is somehow isolated from society, denied an education or access to any form of information, she knows. At least, she knows something. Even if she thinks she has a massive tumor, eventually it will become obvious to anyone with whom she shares a bed or bathroom. Eventually you might get a bit freaked out about what’s happening to your body and say something.

Unless it’s a group denial.

Prove me wrong on this. But I believe any woman who claims a baby popped out of her clear out of the blue is lying or in a state of denial so deep there are psychological underpinnings. 

Why am I driving off the road on this one?

Years ago I covered a preliminary hearing in which the defendant, a college-student who lived at home, hid her pregnancy, gave birth in the family bathroom, wrapped up the newborn and tossed it out the bathroom window into a snowdrift. She was caught by her father who heard “suspicious noises” coming from the bathroom. Soon after, the father saw her walking away from the house with a plastic shopping bag in hand.

Police were called; they intercepted the young woman. Last I heard the baby (who’d now be a teenager) survived. What came out in court, the family’s story, was that no one knew she was pregnant.  It came as a shock to everyone. Their story was hard to believe, but they stood by it.

Mental illness? Overwhelming fear of consequences and judgment? It’s anyone’s guess the reasons for concealment. This isn’t a new story. Concealment of pregnancy isn’t uncommon in teen pregnancies or in places around the world where the consequences are dire. But ignorance of it in a first-world nation? By a woman who has three children already?

As the mother of a teen daughter, the possibility of a pregnancy, along with many other pitfalls of the teen years, crouches in the darker corners of my mind. I’m not saying I suspect anything, but the mothers of these girls are always quoted as saying: “We had no idea this was happening.”

6 thoughts on “I'm not buying this story

  1. Pingback: Anonymous

  2. I recently just watched part of a tv show called something like “She Didn’t Know She Was Pregnant” that featured women who had no idea they were having a baby until they were giving birth. I’ve been pregnant and there’s no way that I wouldn’t have known – I gained 70 pounds all in one place and I got kicked around from the inside a lot. But some women in this show only put on 10 pounds and I know some women don’t get their periods for months at a time due to stress or whatever. I don’t know, I don’t really understand it either. I do know that each pregnancy can be very different so if someone is looking for all of the signs from their first pregnancy they might not consider that they are pregnant again?

  3. The show is a Discovery show: http://health.discovery.com/tv/i-didnt-know-i-was-pregnant/about.html

    I’m not sure I’d believe every story like this but I think it’s possible. In one case the woman had a hard time conceiving her first child and had significant physical issues including problems with her uterus which, in her case, was the doctor’s explanation for not feeling the baby. The doc said that due to the the way her uterus sits, it was entirely possible for her to sail right on through her last trimester and never feel the movements of the baby. Because it took her so long to conceive her first child and she was at such an advanced age, she thought she was actually going through menopause. She didn’t think for a second she could get pregnant again. The others they featured on the episode I watched had thought they were pregnant due to early signs. They took multiple pregnancy tests (including at the doc’s office) that came back negative. They thought they were having other health issues.

    Frankly, I think there are a TON of women out there that aren’t in tune with their bodies. They just aren’t. Either that or they’re like some of the women I know that notice something and then when dismissed by a doctor (initial negative pregnancy test but still feel something is going on), believe him or her as opposed to listening to their bodies. When I was in college I was a nanny for someone who didn’t know until her 7 month. Granted, she was pretty young (college aged). But she’d been an athlete her entire life — which for her meant she never had regular menstrual cycles and she hardly gained any weight and played softball right up until she found out.

    Maybe you’re right about it in most cases. But I do think it’s possible — and not always because of a psychological issue. Although, I think that’s a valid point.

  4. Thanks for the feedback. I am going to look up that show on Discovery; it sounds like a good one. I did do a search around the Web and found some sites that explained some valid medical reasons for women not knowing. The theme of deep denial on a psychological level also came into play. Still, it’s hard to totally believe that, barring extremely unusual circumstances, a woman wouldn’t suspect something was amiss.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

CommentLuv badge